Social Justice
-
Week 9: Reading Guide
Read more: Week 9: Reading GuideThis week, three students will present 15-minute summaries of their final paper concepts. We will also have Jonathan Beckwith as a guest speaker. Readings for the first class are from Beckwith’s book, where he shares several examples of social and ethical implications of research in the life sciences, including the misuse of science to subjugate different groups of people. The last chapter we read this week describes Beckwith’s efforts to work within the existing power structure of biology research to shift it to greater social responsibility. Such change often occurs so slowly that it only becomes apparent after several decades. We will compare the original report of the ELSI Working Group’s plans with a later article seeking to apply the lessons learned to nanotechnology research. The implications for present-day MIT should be apparent.
-
Week 10: Reading Guide
Read more: Week 10: Reading GuideThis week we study the impact of women scientists who spoke out against gender discrimination they experienced at MIT. Led by biologist Nancy Hopkins, all but one of the tenured women faculty in the science departments in 1995 called for investigation and change. In response the Dean of Science formed a committee to investigate, which led to a public report in 1999 that made a big impact not just at MIT, but across higher education and beyond. In 2016, undergraduates Caroline Chen and Kamilla Tekiela co-authored a companion report on the status of undergraduate women at MIT. The issues they identified remain persistent, difficult problems of culture at MIT.
-
Week 11: Reading Guide
Read more: Week 11: Reading GuideThis week we examine the impact of intersectionality theory on activism. Developed by black feminist writers, the concept of intersectionality includes both a categorical element (a person’s combination of multiple social identities) and a political one (the impact of overlapping systems of oppression). An example of the salience of the categorical element can be found in this analysis of MIT climate surveys. The political element, on the other hand, reminds us of the importance of movement spillover and coalition building. Contemporary activists working with an intersectional lens recognize that “injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere” (King) and that single-issue activism often ends up further marginalizing oppressed peoples. As a result, intersectional activists focus on bringing attention to the systemic nature of oppression. They include several notable scientists such as Chanda Prescod-Weinstein and Ben Barres.
-
Week 6: Reading Guide
Read more: Week 6: Reading GuideEach week’s readings will be accompanied by a set of guiding questions. As you read the materials, take notes about key messages as well as questions you have. Class discussions will center around these.
-
Week 3 Reading Guide: The Nuclear Freeze Campaign and the role of organizers
Read more: Week 3 Reading Guide: The Nuclear Freeze Campaign and the role of organizersWe start the first day with a brief discussion of Gusterson’s second article, building on the previous long discussion of the first one. The second part of this discussion is based largely on television interviews of two activist leaders of the campaign for nuclear disarmament. We conclude with Beckwith’s chapter and its relevance to current events at MIT.
-
Week 2: Reading Guide
Read more: Week 2: Reading GuideEach week’s readings will be accompanied by a set of guiding questions. As you read the materials, take notes about key messages as well as questions you have. Class discussions will center around these.
-
Week 1: Reading Guide
Read more: Week 1: Reading GuideEach week’s readings will be accompanied by a set of guiding questions. As you read the materials, take notes about key messages as well as questions you have. Class discussions will center around these.
-
Assignment 4: Food for Free
Read more: Assignment 4: Food for FreePlease write 250-500 words (total) on the following questions.
Please go to Food for Free and have a look at the 2016 report on hunger in Massachusetts and write a reflection answering the questions above with respect to what you learned from these resources about Food for Free’s work.
- Please describe one idea that you found powerful. What message did you get from it?
- Please critically reflect on the message in your own terms. Do you see connections with readings we have done so far on food justice, food security, food sovereignty, the social meaning of food/water, capitalism, labor justice, waste, industrial agriculture?
- If you were to teach someone something you learned from the presentation, what would you tell them?
-
Assignment 2: Flow
Read more: Assignment 2: FlowPlease write 250-500 words (total) on the following questions.
- Please describe one segment of or image from the film Flow that you found powerful. What message did you get from it?
- Please critically reflect on the message in your own terms. Did you see connections with readings we have done so far on global justice, food security, food sovereignty, the social meaning of food/water, capitalism, labor justice?
- If you were to teach someone something you learned from the film, what would you tell them?
-
Assignment 1: Pond and Charity
Read more: Assignment 1: Pond and CharityIn his essay, "Famine, Affluence, and Morality," Singer argues that there is a close analogy between POND and CHARITY (see p. 38 of FES).
- What are the relevant similarities between POND and CHARITY for the purposes of Singer's argument?
- Do you think that the analogy supports his conclusion? Why or why not?
- Suppose someone objected: But in POND, there is one drowning child. In CHARITY, there are too many starving children to help by a single action, so I would have to give something additional up daily for my whole life. This is too much to ask. How would Singer respond?
Notice something that doesn’t seem right? Want to make a suggestion or provide feedback about how something is classified?
Please reach out to esi [at] mit.edu and include SCALES Website in the subject of your email.
Feedback and any actions taken with regards to the feedback, will be shared as they are addressed.