Lesson & Activity Database



 

The Lessons & Activities Database provides instructors with lessons and activities that embody sustainability and climate change. These lessons and activities vary in length and content, and can be added to your existing course, often with small modifications.

 


 

Conduct a search for specific materials!

OR

Browse some of the lessons below.

Prior to selecting a lesson or activity, please remember that you will likely need to make small changes to the provided lessons or activities based on a number of different factors. We trust you as instructors to know what your students are ready for, both academically and emotionally, and how to address certain topics with them, especially when considering the rapport you have with your students and their background knowledge. Please also know that these lessons fall broadly under sustainability, which considers more than just an environmental way of knowing by including economic and social aspects, as well. For example, you may find some lessons and activites that have a broader social focus instead of a solely environmental focus.

We are always excited and eager to engage in further dilogue to assist you as your utilize these materials for your purposes!


Browse Lessons and Activities

Weekly Responses

Each week students will write a very brief (at most 2 paragraphs but could be just bullet points) response to the readings. These might offer comparisons between readings, a summary of the main arguments as you understand them, a series of questions the reading left you with, or if warranted the occasional rant about a particular reading.

Book Review Assignments

The first two writing assignments for this course are to select two of the books we are reading in class and complete a 3–4 page review of them. If there is another book you wish to review, this is fine as long as you seek permission in advance. Such a review should accomplish three things:

Historiographical Essay

For the historiographical essay, you may select your own topic (and within that a framing question) from among those considered in the course. Students should also develop a useful bibliography on the topic. The expectation is that you will encompass a major literature while demonstrating the ability to think critically about the theories and methods engaged by other historians to answer the question you have posed. You should organize the paper around this question, giving careful consideration to why different historians sometimes answer important questions in such different ways.

Practicing Poverty

For the next week, limit your spending to $2 per day. Try to minimize your reliance on pre-existing resources (such as using food that is in the pantry, eating your room-mates leftovers etc.).

Discussion Question - Famine Relief

In his clip from Examined Life, Peter Singer argues that we should all be giving substantial amounts of money and/or time to famine relief, e.g., by giving to Oxfam. He draws on an analogy: suppose you were walking by a shallow pond and a child was drowning. All you need to do to save her life is wade in and help her, though you would ruin your nice shoes. You are morally required to sacrifice your shoes to save the child's life. He argues: children are dying every day from famine. If you restrict yourself to what you really need and sacrifice luxuries, giving the money you save to famine relief, you will save many lives. So you are morally required to do so. What do you think of the analogy? 

 

Discussion Question - Why Eat Less Meat

The website Why Eat Less Meat cites four major reasons to eat less meat: the efficiency of the global food system, the environment, health (both personal and public), and animal welfare. Which of these reasons to eat less meat do you find most compelling? Are any of these reasons (or the combination of them) compelling enough to make you think you personally should eat less meat? Why or why not?

 

Assignment 1: Pond and Charity

In his essay, "Famine, Affluence, and Morality," Singer argues that there is a close analogy between POND and CHARITY (see p. 38 of FES).

  1. What are the relevant similarities between POND and CHARITY for the purposes of Singer's argument?
  2. Do you think that the analogy supports his conclusion? Why or why not?
  3. Suppose someone objected: But in POND, there is one drowning child. In CHARITY, there are too many starving children to help by a single action, so I would have to give something additional up daily for my whole life. This is too much to ask. How would Singer respond?
Assignment 4: Food for Free

Please write 250-500 words (total) on the following questions.

Please go to Food for Free and have a look at the 2016 report on hunger in Massachusetts and write a reflection answering the questions above with respect to what you learned from these resources about Food for Free’s work.

  1. Please describe one idea that you found powerful. What message did you get from it?
  2. Please critically reflect on the message in your own terms. Do you see connections with readings we have done so far on food justice, food security, food sovereignty, the social meaning of food/water, capitalism, labor justice, waste, industrial agriculture?
  3. If you were to teach someone something you learned from the presentation, what would you tell them?
Final Paper

Final Paper for Food Culture and Politics 

Written Assignment 4: Food Memory, Revisited

Short paper as part four of this assignment.

Written Assignment 3: Food Memory

Essay for part three of Food Culture and Politics.

Written Assignments 1 and 2: Cheap Meat

Essay part one for people culture and politics.

Living with AIDS

If you can't make it to the evening film screening, view DVD of Living with AIDS (On the Frontlines of AIDS) on your own time prior to class in Ses #30.

WASH Tutorial

Students, individually, or in groups of two or three, will sign up for and give a 15-minute WASH tutorial to the class on a selected water/sanitation/hygiene topic. Your topic can be on any subject within the field of water, sanitation, hygiene, or environment. Some may focus on specific technologies, while others will do demonstrations, skills training, or share success stories of case studies, designs, policies, plans, or engineered solutions.

WASH Term Project

The main deliverable for the semester is a term project which includes a project proposal, a final class presentation, and participation in the D-Lab Showcase. Guidance on content, structure, etc. of the term project will be provided in class and on the course site. You can select an individual or a team project. For those working in teams, each team member must identify a specific area for which they are responsible and their specific contribution to the overall team. The term project may be done on the same topic as your WASH Tutorial, or it may be a separate topic.

Waste Technology

First Reflection
Subject: Waste Management Technology

Use this reflection to explore a waste management technology with one of three lenses:

  1. Technologies for a specific material stream - Choose one material and examine the technologies used to process / treat that material
  2. Technology Case Study - Choose three areas (cities, communities, government jurisdiction) and compare the technologies used in the three areas
  3. Specific Technology - Explore a technology in depth, its application, scale of use and considerations for purchase and implementation (like cost, size, etc.)
Material Stream

Second Reflection
Subject: Difficult Waste Streams

The goal of this paper is to explore a difficult waste stream by either looking at it through: A specific waste stream and the types of processes / disposal that can be used or evaluating a case study on how a difficult waste stream is disposed in an area.

Difficult wastes are those which can be harmful to human health or the environment, or where the physical properties of the wastes can create serious handling problems.

Partnerships/Enterprises

Third Reflection
Subject: Waste Management Partnership / Enterprise / Actor

The third paper is a chance to select either a:

  • Specific actor (for example: Waste Management, Save that Stuff, Wecyclers, Sanergy, Enevo, etc.)
  • Specific partnership (for example: Casella and the City of Cambridge)

 

Assignment 2: Flow

Please write 250-500 words (total) on the following questions.

  1. Please describe one segment of or image from the film Flow that you found powerful. What message did you get from it?
  2. Please critically reflect on the message in your own terms. Did you see connections with readings we have done so far on global justice, food security, food sovereignty, the social meaning of food/water, capitalism, labor justice?
  3. If you were to teach someone something you learned from the film, what would you tell them?
Homework 1

Problem set from the class Fundamentals of Advanced Energy Conversion at MIT.

Homework 2

Problem set from the class Fundamentals of Advanced Energy Conversion at MIT.

Homework 3

Problem set from the class Fundamentals of Advanced Energy Conversion at MIT.

Homework 4

Problem set with calculations from the Fundamentals of Advanced Energy Conversion course at MIT. 

Homework 5

Problem set from the class Fundamentals of Advanced Energy Conversion.

Term Project

The purpose of the term projects is to research and study an energy conversion technology in greater depth than possible in class. The project should incorporate thermodynamic analysis if dealing with thermal energy as well as the energy source/fuel, methods of conversion, targeted power range, political and economic constraints, and competing technologies. A technical report and a presentation session will be the final deliverables for the project.

Paper 1

Please write an essay addressing ONE of the following questions. Your essay should be between 1000 and 1500 words. Please also consider:

  • For this essay, you should use (discuss, reference, quote) at least 5 of the readings from session 1–5.
  • While developing your argument include the analysis of 2–3 case studies (countries/environmental conflicts/regions).
  • You should bring a draft (printed copy of at least 700 words) to session 6.
  • A complete draft (100-1500 words) should be submitted (printed copy) on session 7. This draft is part of your final grade.
Paper 2: Providing Expert Advice

Wakanda's president recently created an interagency commission to address the challenges and opportunities in developing a policy framework of this nature. The interagency commission has called for a group of experts including: industrial leaders, worker's unions, local communities, scientists, social scientists, policy scholars, and foreign experts on comparative environmental governance.

You are one of the members of this last group. Your job is to advise how to better discuss, design, and implement a policy framework considering ecological, social, economic, and political aspects.

Final Project: Essay & Digital Communications Project
  • Choose a problem that is useful to show what you have learned in this class. Nexus approach? Social or political dimensions of technology? Social histories of institutions, policy entrepreneurs, or bilateral activists? socioecological impacts of production/consumption systems?
  • Pay attention to what problem/theme/topic might be professionally useful for you in the future. Something that you can show you have researched in the past? Something that could serve as the first exploration for a future research or project?

 

Personal Energy Consumption

Determine your average daily energy consumption (in kWh). For this assignment, you can take into account only the electricity that you use, though you should be aware that there are additional energy expenditures in terms of transportation, heating, manufacturing processes to make the products that you use, etc. You should submit this as a table showing your energy consumption (power x time) for a few days and then come up with an average value.

Problem Set 0

Using the given LED (3.6V, 20mA) and 9V battery provided in class, a resistor of your choosing, and found materials, construct a lantern. The lantern should be able to turn on and off.

Problem Set 1

Problem set for the course D-Lab: Energy.

Problem Set 2: Personal Energy Consumption Challenge

Problem set for the course D-Lab: Energy.

Problem Set 3

Problem set for the course D-Lab: Energy.

Wiki Design Notebook

Each week, your team should update your team’s wiki page. If you do a great job documenting everything, it will make your final report much, MUCH easier to write.

The wiki should include key documents (project specs, etc.), an ever-changing schedule, photos from experiments, scans of best brainstormed ideas, etc. It should also contain a weekly report on your communications with your community partner (you should do everything in your power — regular emails and/or phone calls to stay in touch) so that they are up to date on your progress and can offer feedback.

Initial Design Review

At this review, you’ll have 10 minutes to present your project, and then 15 minutes for discussion and questions. You should bring your working prototype and show it working.

Final Design Review & Presentations

Each team will prepare the following: one-minute presentation; poster session and final design review.

Final Report

The purpose of the final report is to document your project so that community partners and/or future students interested in your work can understand it, avoid repetition, and make further progress. As a team, write a 12-15 page report describing your project.

Problem Set 1

These problems are not written to be mathematically challenging. Instead, the main challenge is to find reliable data and use sound reasoning. For each of the problems you work out, provide a list of sources for any data you used. Be sure to mark which course number you are registered for on your solution. You can turn in the homework online (via Stellar) or in class.

Problem Set 2

Problem set for the course Introduction to Sustainable Energy.

Problem Set 3

Problem set for the course Introduction to Sustainable Energy.

Problem Set 4

Problem set for the course Introduction to Sustainable Energy.

Problem Set 5

Problem set for the course Introduction to Sustainable Energy.

Problem Set 6

Problem set for the course Introduction to Sustainable Energy.

Problem Set 7

Problem set for the course Introduction to Sustainable Energy.

Problem Set 8

Problem set for the course Introduction to Sustainable Energy.

Sustainable Energy Take-Home Exam 1

This is a take-home quiz. You may use any class notes, texts, or other reliable sources that you wish, but be sure to cite any sources you use. State all assumptions made.

Take-Home Exam 2

This is a take-home quiz. You may use any class notes, texts, or other reliable sources that you wish, but be sure to cite any sources you use. State all assumptions made.

Final Exam

This is a take-home quiz. You may use any class notes, texts, or other reliable sources that you wish, but be sure to cite any sources you use. State all assumptions made.

Term Paper

The term paper is to answer a question based upon information available in the literature. It is not a research paper, demanding original intellectual contributions. Your paper should answer the question, noting important uncertainties, areas of unavailable knowledge and including a critique of the information in the literature. You should not become an advocate for a policy or position. Please choose a topic that is of interest for a term paper. Do not pick a topic that you are working on or have worked on as a project already – we want you to look into something outside of your main expertise.

Responses Paper

A response paper communicates your intellectual reactions to an idea in the articles and papers we read for class. Much like a book review, the response paper usually provides your overall point of view regarding the material read. 

Final Research Papers

Students completed four two-page reaction papers, one 25-page final research paper, and presented a summary of their final paper in class.

Final Research Presentation

Students completed four two-page reaction papers, one 25-page final research paper, and presented a summary of their final paper in class.

Final Website

First, the class must create a content-rich web site to describe and justify its overall design.

Final Presentation

Second, the class will make a final, one-two hour, oral presentation of its solution in early December. This presentation will be open to the entire MIT community. In addition, a panel of experts will be invited to attend the presentation and to critique them in an open forum. Because it would be logistically difficult for everyone to speak during the presentation, the staff recommends that each team elect one member to join a presentation committee that will choreograph the final presentation. The committee member should not bear sole responsibility for the work involved in developing the presentation!

Case Question 1

The following selected case has questions to be addressed and written up. Students should work in teams of three to four. The questions address aspects of the case that need further analysis.

Case: "U.S. Current Account Deficit," HBS 9706002.

Is the US sustainable? Find in trading economics the CA and Wage Changes in any of the last three years and do a BBNN diagnostic!

Case Question 2

Case Write-up Questions
The following selected case has questions to be addressed and written up. Students should work in teams of three to four. The questions address aspects of the case that need further analysis.

Case: "Menem and the Populist Tradition in Argentina," HBS 9700061.

Explain 3 events from the case (such as devaluations, policy choices, growth, change in export prices, etc.). Do the diagnostic, and explain the impact using the BBNN.

Case Question 3

Case Write-up Questions
The following selected case has questions to be addressed and written up. Students should work in teams of three to four. The questions address aspects of the case that need further analysis.

Case: "New Theories of International Trade," HBS 9390001.

Should UK remain in the European Union? (yes, no) What are the advantages of Protection?

Case Question 4

Case Write-up Questions
The following selected case has questions to be addressed and written up. Students should work in teams of three to four. The questions address aspects of the case that need further analysis.

Case: "Reforming Social Security Around the World," Kellogg KEL493.

Answer for one country only: How would you change the social security system in (US, France, or Japan)?

Case Question 5

Case Write-up Questions
The following selected case has questions to be addressed and written up. Students should work in teams of three to four. The questions address aspects of the case that need further analysis.

Case: "A Framework to Think About Pollution," Darden UV5687.

Comment the following Statement: Carbon Tax Markets have the chance to solve the property rights problem that exists in CO2 emissions.

Case Question 6

Case Write-up Questions
The following selected case has questions to be addressed and written up. Students should work in teams of three to four. The questions address aspects of the case that need further analysis.

In one page! What is the solution to the problem of income inequality in a developed nation?

Problem Set 2

This problem set reviews your knowledge of multivariate regression analysis. 

Problem Set 3

Problem set for the course Energy Economics

Problem Set 4

Problem set for the cousre Energy Economics

Problem Set 5

Problem set from the course Energy Economics.

Problem Set 6

Problem set from the course Energy Economics.

Problem Set 7

Problem set from the course Energy Economics

Assignment 1

Problem set for the course Environmental Policy and Economics. 

Assignment 2

Problem set for the course Environmental Policy and Economics. 

Assignment 3

Problem set for the course Environmental Policy and Economics. 

Assignment 4

Problem set for the course Environmental Policy and Economics. 

Assignment 5

Problem set for the course Environmental Policy and Economics. 

Midterm Exam

Midterm Exam for the course Environmental Policy and Economics. 

Forecasting

Problem set on forecasting from the course D-Lab: Supply Chains.

Process Analysis

Problem set on forecasting from the course D-Lab: Supply Chains.

Inventory Models

Problem set on forecasting from the course D-Lab: Supply Chains.

Contracts and Procurement

Problem set on forecasting from the course D-Lab: Supply Chains.

OPT Production Game Assignment

Your assignment is to schedule a small job-shop with the objective to maximize your cash after two weeks. You start with $1500 and you must pay a fixed operating cost of $2500 at the end of each week. There are no loans available and you go out of business if you run out of cash.

Discussion Questions

Please answer the following questions (maximum 2 single-spaced pages). Make sure to use examples from the reading where applicable.

  1. What 2 major crises did the Brandt Report predict? How accurate were these predictions?
  2. What is the effect of tariffs on raw vs. processed vs. manufactured goods?
  3. On p. 4 the author states: "Never before in history have so many non-technical people exerted so much influence on the advancement, retardation, and movement of technology." Comment on this trend and give an example that illustrates it.
Stakeholder Analysis Writeup

Smith, Amy, and Shawn Frayne. "Fuel from the Fields: A Case Study of Sugarcane Charcoal Technology in Petite Anse, Haiti." D-Lab Case Study. (PDF - 1.4MB)

Blank stakeholder analysis form (PDF)

Small is Beautiful Reaction Piece

Write a one-page reaction piece to the following reading. What did you find interesting? What insights did you gain? Do you agree or disagree with the author? Did you gain any new perspectives? 

Discussion Questions: Mastering the Machine 2

Please answer the following questions (maximum 2 single-spaced pages), using examples from the book where applicable.

  1. Do small farms have a place in the future of agriculture? The world economy? Food security? If so, how?
  2. How do the lessons learned from the Turkana rainwater harvesting project contrast with the actions taken during the green revolution?
  3. Why is there so much focus on post-harvest technology, and value-added production?
Current Events

Review both the national and international media to find a story that affects your D-Lab project country. Some sectors that might be of interest include: the environment, health and sanitation, agriculture, energy, education, humanitarian disaster, politics, economics and information technology. Each person on your D-Lab country team should select a different topic. Write a 2-page summary of the story making sure to comment on its implications for the nation, your D-Lab trip or another affected group. Make sure to properly cite all your sources.

Practical Photovoltaics Design

You are in charge of designing a solar panel installation for a rural health post. The requirements for the given location are as follows:

  • There is a 220W freezer that needs to run 24/7
  • The health post is open until 9pm, and, on average, they have to turn the lights on from 6pm until they close. Given their needs, it seems that the most adequate installation would be 2 fluorescent lights of 15W each.
  • They have an amateur radio to communicate with the clinic in the city, that consumes 40W, and it is usually on for two hours every day.
  • The health post is staffed every day of the year.

 

Trip Project Proposal

This form will allow the D-Lab staff to provide feedback and help you prepare for your project. You should fill in a form for each project you are working on, but only one of them will be turned in to be graded. You should continue to refine the proposals throughout the semester.

 

Discussion Questions: Mastering the Machine 3

See [Smillie], pp. 44-66. Please answer the following questions (maximum 2 single-spaced pages), using examples from the book where applicable.

  1. According to the reading, what are some of the major reasons why NGOs and the Third Sector developed such an important role in what we call 'international development'?
  2. What are some of the advantages and disadvantages of NGO organizational structure? Use some examples from the reading.
  3. What is meant by 'civil society'? In what ways might the concepts described by this term influenced the development of D-Lab philosophy?
Drowned Out

If you can't make it to the evening film screening, view DVD of Drowned Out on your own time prior to class on Ses #25.

Sector Paper

Write a five-page paper (double-spaced, not including figures, tables or pictures) describing the current state of affairs in your country in one of the sectors that we have studied in class:

Quiz 2

This is a quiz, with open-ended questions from D-Lab I: Development.

Lab Notebook Review

Each class member is required to keep an up-to-date design notebook throughout the term. It is a good design practice to carefully document the history of your work. Also, notebooks are required in professional practice.

 

CI Reports

Both of these reports should be well-structured, with introductions, body and conclusions. 

  • Review of a current (major) engineering challenge and why it’s important to society today. Stories taken from current news and events, and popular magazines (Popular Science, Science, Nature, Scientific American, New Scientist, Time, US News and World Reports, etc) related to major engineering challenges facing society today. 
  • Ethics position paper (PDF). This position paper will convey your personal opinion relating to the ethical dilemma presented in an assigned reading. You will not be graded on your opinion, but how you convince the reader that your opinion is valid and should be considered. This should be approximately 2 pages
Oral Presentation

Your team will make a presentation to the class on your design ideas and how you plan to construct your vehicle. This presentation should be made in Powerpoint (MAC/Windows) or Keynote (MAC OS) and a PDF should be printed and posted to the course Web site. Each team member should present some aspect of the design.

Technical Reports

Both of these reports should be well-structured, with introductions, body and conclusions. 

  1. Technical report 1 (PDF): This TR will detail the data obtained from testing the motors. Highlight the pros/cons of the motor/prop combination and present your data for thrust, etc.
  2. Technical report 2: This TR will detail your data collected in the Charles River Basin and Boston Harbor areas.
Labs

A list of labs and their associated directions for the course Exploring Sea, Space & Earth: Fundamentals of Engineering Design

In the Elevator or Hallway: Talking Informally about Science

Come to class prepared to speak informally and briefly (maximum 2 minutes) about a topic in science, technology, or engineering that interests you. Assume your audience is intelligent but knows little or nothing about the subject.

What Does It Mean to Write About Science for the Public

The readings for this session are two different accounts on the discovery of the structure of DNA. When reading them, take into account the discussion we will have comparing and contrasting both what they say and their ways of saying it.

Telling a Tale, Painting a Picture: Writing About Science Using Special Techniques

Come to class with a first draft of a one-page description of a phenomenon in science for a public audience, a one-page essay on a topic related to science, or a one-page letter to the editor responding to a recent op-ed on a topic in science or technology.

Workshop: Writing Science and Writing Science (cont.)

Revise your one-page written piece to include the elements you recently learned.

 

Critiquing Science on Display

Please tour the public galleries on display in the lobbies of the Broad Institute and the Koch Institute, which face one another across Main Street on the MIT campus. Then write brief notes (2–3 pages) that critically compare and contrast the approaches to exhibiting science of these two galleries.

Science in the Blogosphere

Identify a science blog of your choice from the Discover Magazine “stable” of blogs available at: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/, follow it for at least three days during the week preceding this class, and write a short critical review of it. What is the blog trying to do, and how well is it doing it? Come to class prepared to give a short (2 minute) review of your chosen blog.

From Cancer Cells to String Theory: Communicating Complex Material

After completing the readings for this session, please write what you think did and did not work about the communication used.

Assignment 1: Elemental Case Study

Small group project exploring the urban/planning implications of water, food, “nature” (however specifically defined), energy, and communications in the Boston area. Each small group will be assigned an “element” to research and document.

 

Assignment 2: Site Probes

In teams of 1, 2, OR 3, students will conduct visits to sites of their own choice. Using direct observation, photography, mapping, and online data collection, you will “probe” your site, uncovering social, political, economic, physical, and environmental conditions specific to that place.

Assignment 3: Big Plan

In Assignment 1, you explored the city through large-scale processes. In Assignment 2, you focused on unearthing key issues in specific Boston/Cambridge neighborhoods. For your final assignment, you will form your own vision, your own Big Plan.

Weekly Reading and Class Responses

You are required to submit a one-paragraph (no more than 150 words) response to the readings each week by 4pm the night before class. The responses are not meant to be formal, but instead help you engage with the class material and help us lead and focus the class discussion. You should not spend more than 30 minutes each week on the responses, although we expect you will spend significantly more time doing readings. 

Counting and Observing at Key Intersections (Assignment 1)

The first assignment is a group assignment, to go out and observe key street cross sections and intersections nearby in Cambridge. This assignment gives you a chance to observe and think about how people, different travel modes, infrastructure, and neighboring land uses interact in a real, live place. You will not only look and see what is going on, but also start to become familiar with how "little numbers" translate to real-world conditions: what does 800 cars/hour look like vs. 800 people riding the T, and what impact do these differences have on the nature of the urban scene? You should become familiar with basic ideas like level of service, saturation flow rate, capacity, speeds, flow, and mode share (see Meyer and Miller, Chapter 3). We want you to think about how you measure and what you measure, and what impact this has on the transportation planning process and built outcomes.

Re-Designing Massachusetts Avenue (Assignment 2)

The Cambridge Director of Transportation has asked you, his trusted advisor, to help him plan his strategy with respect to current issues regarding Massachusetts Avenue between Central Square and the Harvard Bridge.

For this assignment, you will have access to the counting reports of the teams at three intersections and locations along Mass. Ave. You should walk and observe, and use the first several steps of the 19 step process as part of your background work in preparing to write the assignment. Pay explicit attention to the first step: "who are you?" and how this impacts the advice you give.

Assessing the Impacts of Growth in Lower Mystic (Assignment 3)

A 15 page (max) double-spaced memo to the Boston Chief of Streets

Planning for Growth in the Lower Mystic (Assignment 4)

After assessing the level of growth projected from the various developments in the Lower Mystic area, the impacts and capacity constraints of major transportation infrastructure in the area, and projected and estimated mode shares, now it's your turn to propose as individuals how to achieve a transportation plan that can maintain and improve access to jobs and opportunities while supporting the plans and goals of the surrounding cities.

My Energy Essay (Assignment 1)

 In this first assignment you are invited to reflect about your past and envision your future building energy use.

 

Shading Studies & Sun Path Diagrams (Assignment 2)

The objective of this assignment is to validate the results of direct shading studies provided by DIVA/Radiance and other tools. To do so, you are asked to take a photo of an object of your choice outside at least twice at different times of day under clear sky conditions. You are then asked to model the object in Rhino and generate two clear sky visualizations under the same sky conditions from about the same perspective as the photo. 

Visual and Thermal Comfort (Assignment 3)

The objectives of this assignment are for you to develop a feeling for indoor environmental variables that have an impact on thermal comfort and to compare your personal sensation to comfort predictions based on thermal and lighting standards. The assignment is split into two components:  

  • Task A: Using a data logger, measure “your life” on a psychrometric chart over a couple of days.  
  • Task B: Measure indoor environmental conditions in two spaces that you find comfortable and uncomfortable and compare your assessments to that of current thermal comfort standards. 

 

Designing a PV System (Assignment 4)

During assignment 1 you determined how much electricity you have used at some point in your life living in an apartment or house. In this assignment you are going to design a PV system that yields the same amount of electricity over the course of a year and calculate the simple payback time required to get your investment back. The assignment is broken into three parts. 

Daylight Availability Study (Assignment 5)

In this assignment you will start working in groups on your final course project which is the development of an environmental design concept for an about 3500m2 innovation/startup space located in either Chicago, Houston or Seattle, depending on which city you previously signed up for. Your building should accommodate work spaces for around 250 workers, a reception area, lavatory, two seminar rooms and a cafe (optional). It is up to you to define the final program. You may pick any available site within your city and should also consider external factors such as a site’s walkscore etc. Remember to include neighboring buildings in your shading and daylighting analysis. The goal of this first assignment is to develop and evaluate a series of massing options and façade designs that you will then further refine in future assignments.

Visual Comfort and Electric Lighting (Assignment 6)

The goal of this assignment is check your final daylighting design from Assignment 5 for potential areas of glare and remedy them as well as to design an electric lighting concept for your design. As a target level, the electric lighting should provide around 300lux on all key working surfaces and around 150lux in all circulation areas.

Energy Explorations (Assignment 7)

Now that you have a well daylit, visually comfortable building with an electric lighting design in place, we are turning our attention towards evaluating and improving the energy performance of your design. In this assignment you will first create a baseline energy model of your building and then explore various energy updates.

Simulation Game Analysis (Assignment 8)

The objective of the game is to redesign your class project, with the lowest possible operational Source Energy Use Intensity (Source EUI, kWh/m2) as simulated in DIVA/Archsim/EnergyPlus. Starting off with an approximate thermal model of your latest design from Assignment 6, your task is to create a version of your building with the lowest Source EUI and a purchasing budget at or under $50 MIT dollars. The team with the largest proportional EUI reduction vis-à-vis their baseline design wins. Follow all rules below. When time is up (after 80 minutes), your team must save all of your files and submit them along with a detailed description of your final designs and how you arrived at your best performing iteration.

Course Project

As announced in the course syllabus, the final course deliverable is the presentation of an environmental design concept for the 3500m2 innovation/startup space that you have been working on since assignment 5. The final presentation should last for 12 minutes plus 3 minutes for Q&A and draw from the material that you have generated during previous assignments. You may want to add some additional work to create a coherent project narrative.

Course Project

The course is designed around collaborations focused on specific student deliverables. My intention is to create student “teams” among class members who will collaborate on specific short-term activities that will build on ongoing research and inform the ultimate class output, a response to the Draft Interim CECP, including (1) a meta-analysis of recent surveys of current, former, and potential transit riders, geared toward understanding attitudes toward personal mobility and transit specifically, and how they may have evolved, and (2) a similar analysis of global “best practices” in connection with transit operations designed to ensure public health and rider confidence. This will require review of relevant material (which will be included in the readings) and additional (reasonably modest) research to identify gaps, new material, and insights that combine to synthesize extant research and surveys relevant to the course purpose.

 

Online Blog - Research and Reflective Practice

Students will be expected to keep a blog where reflection assignments will be completed weekly. These assignments are geared to explore issues faced by planners during the planning process as well as document student professional growth and experiences working in multi-disciplinary teams. 

Disaster Mitigation Plans, Planners & Policies

Students will explore and analyze a mitigation plan in a U.S. city or town.

What is your town’s Mitigation Plan?

Decide on a town to research. We prefer that you use your hometown, if possible. As someone from the town, you will better understand town dynamics, town threats, town government, and maybe even town politics.

Find a copy of your town’s mitigation plan, if there is one, and analyze the plan.

Field Research and Report

In this second phase, student teams will undertake in-depth research, analysis and design in project areas in Valparaíso. Once on the ground, students need to understand the requirements needed to realize goals and opportunities of the projects by assessing existing resources and assets, identifying critical obstacles and resources gaps to address, and defining other factors that shape effective strategies and interventions to generate the client’s desired revitalization goals for the district.

Poster & Presentation

Create a poster about your project. Your poster should speak to the planning issue(s) in New Orleans that you are researching and writing about. What question can you ask that will pull a reader into your poster and get him/her thinking about your project? What issues are you working on? What data have you gathered? What story can you tell about your planning issue in New Orleans?

OR

Alternatively, create a poster for your client's needs. This poster could inform neighborhood groups about a particular planning issue. This poster could graphically showcase how citizens can understand design standards easily and efficiently, and/or this poster could help citizens understand the importance of using public transportation. In other words, it could be used as part of a community campaign to bring attention to a planning issue in New Orleans. Posters will be made part of an exhibit that showcases the work of our students working in New Orleans. Posters should be 20”x30”, either direction.

Journal

Document your own thoughts, comments, and challenges on the readings and class material. The journal may be of any length or medium, but should discuss at least two readings/topics.

Urban Change (Assignment 1)

This assignment addresses the underlying urban dynamics that are causing a city to change. It also seeks to develop or sharpen your skills of observation, encouraging you to make inferences from the evidence of the physical environment and to test these through interviews and research.

 

Pre-Travel Tutorial

Students are expected to commit 5+ hours a week during November and December in a guided self-study on Malaysian culture, history, politics, geography, planning and economics. Students write three short response papers based on the assigned readings and are encouraged to integrate any additional readings on Malaysia beyond what is assigned. Students are also required to write a short topical literature review on a theme of their choice that is specific to a Malaysian city of focus

National Environmental Policy-making

Given what you have read in Unit 1 and what we have discussed in class, provide the simplest model you can of national environmental policy-making for any country you choose. 

Environmental Ethics

Traditionally economists have argued that humans are utility maximizers, although some behavioral economists and social psychologists have recently raised questions about this. With this in mind, please write a paper addressing the following questions.

Environmental Assessment

Most environmental planners presume that policy decisions regarding the use of natural resources and patterns of development can be enhanced through the application of various analytical tools.

  1. Explain why and how you agree or disagree with this, with reference to each of the tools discussed in Unit 3.
  2. What do you think are the relative strengths and limitations of each of the analytical tools we discussed in Unit 3?
Public Participation and Group Decision-Making

There is an ongoing debate between political philosophers and dispute resolution professionals regarding the most appropriate means of conceptualizing the public interest (with regards to the use of natural resources or patterns of urban development). The philosophers believe "deliberative polling" that provides a snapshot of what the "average citizen" prefers should be sufficient for elected officials to determine what actions to take in the public interest. Dispute resolution professionals argue the public interest can best be understood as the product of a consensus building dialogue among contending interests (not individuals) and that public officials armed with polling data can never know or produce on their own the public interest.

Scenario Presentations

Each student must make three oral presentations focused on three of the 14 scenarios available in this section. Two students will sign up at the start of the semester for each scenario. The third presenter will be selected at the beginning of the class to speak about that day's scenario. Students will be graded on both their answers to the assigned questions and the clarity of their presentation. Short descriptions are provided below. These presentations account for up to 30 points of your final grade.

 

Final Exam

You will need to write three short essays for the final:

  • Choose any three questions from the options below.
  • Your responses should be approximately 500 words. Do not exceed 800 words for any answer. Include your word count below each response.
  • Please include your name at the top of the document and the question number next to each response.

 

Journals

In many fields, the journal (or sketchbook, field notebook, or lab book) is an important aid both to the process of research and discovery, and to the documentation of that process and its product, the findings, in more formal papers or books.

Your journal is a place to begin puzzling out some of the ideas that you will explore further in each of four assignments: Select A Site; Natural Processes; Change Over Time; and Traces and Trends. The first step in preparing to write the journal is to read the guide for that assignment: to familiarize yourself with what the assignment is asking you to do; to figure out what kind of background information and evidence you will need to accomplish that task. You will gather that information and evidence in class discussion, in the required readings, and on field trips.

Select a Site

In 2016, MIT will celebrate the hundredth anniversary of its move from Boston's Back Bay to the current location in Cambridge. To honor that occasion, this year the class will focus on MIT's former and current neighborhoods, so you should select a site within the designated boundaries in Cambridge or the Back Bay. The site should be between four and eight blocks. Ideally, it should include more than one type of land use. And it should be a place that intrigues you. Reflect on why it interests you, why you are drawn to it. What questions does the place raise, for which you hope to find answers this semester?

 

Your Site and Natural Processes

This is the second part of a four-part, semester-long project. The first part consisted of finding a site. Now the task is to find evidence on your site of its environmental history and ongoing natural processes. The objective, through the examination of your site and its context, is to explore how natural processes shape cities.

 

Your Site through Time

This is the third part of a four-part, semester-long project. The first part consisted of finding a site; the second, to find evidence of its environmental history and ongoing natural processes. Now the task is to trace changes on your site over time by comparing its character at several points in time, using maps. You may find different kinds of changes: Land use, density of settlement, additions to buildings, ownership, transportation. The types of sources you will find helpful are historical maps, especially nineteenth and twentieth-century atlases, and may also include plans, prints, and photographs. 

Artifacts, Layers, Traces, and Trends

Now the objective is to find traces of these changes present in the current environment and to interpret their significance. Many of you were attracted to your site because of some anomalous features that puzzled you and made you wonder why they were there and what had caused them to be. This is an opportunity to explore some answers to such puzzles.

Assignment 1

While you are free to construct your house entirely on the basis of your design and modeling skills and your physical intuition, please consider making use of provided software to guide you in choices about windows and insulation. We will use several versions of this software throughout the lab to compare prediction with performance. The elf house should be ready next week to be placed on the roof for an initial, one-week test period. Please come to lab next week prepared to finish the construction during the first half of our session. We’ll then activate and insert the temperature loggers and place the houses on the roof . We’ll also work with the data from the potatoes and continue to work with the software. 

Assignment 2

The second phase of our first lab consists of three parts: 

  1.  Please calculate the thermal time constant, in minutes, from your experimental data, using the three methods to be given in lab this week.
  2. Construction of solar building. Please complete the construction of your solar building, using the design specifications given in lab last week.
  3. Estimation of air temperature inside your house.
Assignment 3

The third phase of our first lab consists of six parts: 

  1. Submit your estimate of your elf-house temperatures for the first test period.
  2. Download data.
  3. Modify your elf house as needed to keep the indoor temperature closer to the target value of 20°C. 
  4. Re-install the Hobo loggers and again deploy your house on the roof.
  5. Estimate the impact of solar energy absorbed on walls and the roof.  
  6. Use Solar Calculator 2 to design a full-size dwelling (single room is fine), subject to the same goal of a constant 20°C indoor temperature under February weather. 
Assignment 4

The fourth and last phase of our first lab consists of the following: 

  1. Download data from your second test period, which should be a week long and a minimum of six days. 
  2. Compare your measured data with an after-the-fact prediction made with measured outdoor temperature and solar radiation. 
  3. Adapt the provided Matlab .m file to accurately simulate your elf house. 
  4. Prepare a 10-minute presentation for lab next week to describe your work, which should include all data and as much analysis as you have been able to perform. No need to cover Mr. Potato Head. No late presentations, please!
  5. Prepare a written lab report using the provided checklist and submit the report in lab in two weeks. 
Assignment 5

The goal of this assignment, the first phase of the lab project that focuses on airflows and building ventilation, is to design, construct in model form, and test an enclosure (partial or full) for a typical balcony for a Chinese apartment. The motivation for this work is to propose feasible designs for Chinese residential buildings that are thermally comfortable and use a minimal amount of energy.

Assignment 6

The second week of our airflow lab focuses on airflow measurements and analysis.

 

Assignment 7

The third week of our airflow lab focuses on simulation:

  1. Prepare to use the CONTAMW airflow simulation program, installed on two working computers in lab and available free to all with Windows computers. 
  2. Become proficient in CONTAMW by completing the provided worksheet.
  3. Use CONTAMW for the following investigation of your apartment-balcony, working at full (and not model) scale:

 

Assignment 8

The fourth week of our airflow lab is in two phases: 

  1. Please prepare an occupants’ manual for your Chinese apartment. Passively conditioned buildings require occupant involvement, much more than buildings with mechanical systems that ensure thermostat set points are maintained. Your apartment occupants can inhabit any of the rooms and can adjust the balcony openings and apartment windows and doors in a number of ways, for different wind and outdoor temperature conditions. 
  2. Please consider the effect of airflow on the rate at which a miniature structure (even smaller than our elf houses) cools off. This is intended to combine thermal and airflow analysis.
Assignment 9

Please read Chapters 1 and 2 of our textbook, Joseph Murdoch's Illuminating Engineering. How to do this

Please take on the following tasks:

  1. Illuminance measurements. Use an illuminance meter to record light levels in residential spaces, including those used for food preparation, reading, and such detailed manual labor as sewing or electronics repair (i.e., a home shop or work room).
  2. Review IES illuminance criteria (from Murdoch or, better, the IES Handbooks which are in the lab and in the Rotch reference collection) for activities you think appropriate for a Gujarati house.
  3. Define desired lighting levels and any issues about light quality for a Gujarati house, on the basis of Tasks 1 and 2.
  4. Use the illuminance meter to estimate reflectances for typical walls and floors, including those in your test rooms.
  5. Review IES data on surface reflectances.
  6. Define desired wall, floor and ceiling reflectances for upcoming daylighting models of Gujarati houses.
  7. Select a Gujarati house, select modeling materials, and construct a model. Please pay attention to:
  8. Accurate dimensions, with careful notes about choices when available information is inadequate.
Assignment 10

Please read Chapter 3 (sections 1-6 and 10 only), Chapter 5 (sections 1-12 only, unless you are ambitious), and Chapter 7 of our textbook, Joseph Murdoch's Illuminating Engineering. 

Please take a set of base-case measurements in your Gujarati house.

Assignment 11

Please design roof opening(s) for your Gujarati house and test it with a second round of daylighting measurements.

Assignment 12

The final lap around the track in BT Lab is a daylighting simulation for your house.

Assignment 1 - Hometown Analysis

A critical part of creating policy is the data gathering process. What data can you find quickly and analyze? What do the data mean? What story can you tell using reliable data? What data do you need?

Using your hometown as the subject of your investigation, assume that you are a policy analyst and you work for the new mayor or the new town or city council.

What data can you use to tell a story about your hometown? Where is it located? How many people live there? What does it provide in terms of resources to the state?

Assignment 2 - EPA Open Docket on Pesticides

The EPA has opened docket ID: EPA-HQ-OPP-2008-0844 to review neonicotinoids, pesticides that may have an adverse effect on pollinators, including bees. You have been asked by your client to review the EPA primary and supporting documents and provide a 2-page memo of comments to the EPA stating your position. You may choose your client. Decide who you will represent—an advocacy group, a state environmental protection agency, a farmer, etc.

Assignment 3 - Observe a Public Meeting

Attend a public meeting in the Boston area, take careful notes on the event, and report back in a succinct, well-organized informational memo. Be sure to also collect any materials distributed at the event for reference. Your memo should describe the organization, discuss where its power originates, identify the purpose of the meeting, explain the structure of the deliberative process used to collect input, and discuss what, if any, outcome resulted.

Final Assignment

Directions:

  1. Identify a narrow policy issue of your choice (take a look at the materials provided for various case studies on the course website if you are having trouble picking a topic);
  2. Present an analysis of the policy issue;
  3. Identify alternative policies;
  4. Evaluate and analyze the policy you are studying using cost-benefit analysis, stakeholder analysis, data analysis, and / or analysis of inputs, outputs, and outcomes;
  5. Apply the correct type(s) of policy analysis to the alternatives;
  6. Present the results of your analysis and the give the best option based on your criteria; and
  7. Make suggestions for implementing, monitoring, and evaluating the policy.

 

Urban Plans (Assignment 2)

The purpose of this exercise is to explore the nature of plans and their impact on the form and function of cities. We are interested in the motivations for creating plans, the processes by which they are prepared, the languages of urban design which underlay them, and the long-term effects of plans -- or lack thereof -- on the city. Having considered these issues, you are asked to answer the question: What makes a good plan?

 

Final Research Paper

Students are also responsible for a 20 page research paper exploring an environmental issue in which they are interested and which will be due in the final class. 

Reaction Papers

Students are responsible for writing a 1–2 page reaction paper based on the readings (or another assigned topic) for each week's class for a total of eight reaction papers. Papers are due in the class for which the reading is assigned. Reaction papers are your personal response to the week's readings. These papers should offer an overview of the main points of the book or articles under consideration. It should also include your own assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of these readings and, if possible, should link the reading at hand to other readings from the course or topics discussed in class.

 

Homework 1: Visualization Blog

Write a post on the class blog about a data presentation you saw recently (250ish words). Include a link and a picture/screenshot of the presentation. Make sure to address:

  • what data is being shown
  • who you think the audience is
  • what you think the goals of the data presentation are
  • whether you think it is effective or not and why
Assignment 5: Personal Reflection

Please write 250-500 words (total) addressing the questions below.

  1. Please describe one idea you encountered during this course that you found powerful.
  2. Please critically reflect on the idea in your own terms. What makes it powerful or meaningful to you? How is it related to things you had thought before taking the course? How does it connect (or disconnect) with ideas that you take to be common or popular?
  3. Is there any way in which the course has affected your actions and choices (note that “not at all” is an option!)? Do you think any of the arguments should prompt you to change your actions, even you aren’t inclined to change? Are there ways they may change your actions in the future? (Why or why not?)
Week 5: Reading Guide

Each week’s readings will be accompanied by a set of guiding questions. As you read the materials, take notes about key messages as well as questions you have. Class discussions will center around these.

Ocean Carbon System

In this problem set you will calculate the amount of anthropogenic CO2 taken up by the ocean when ocean parameters have changed in response to global climate change.

Ocean and Climate

Problem set focused on paleoclimate from the course Climate Physics and Chemistry.

Discussion Question - Ecology

In the transcript of Slavoj Žižek’s conversation from Examined Life, he says, "the true ecologist must also accept that nature is the ultimate human myth, that we humans, when we perceive ourselves as beyond nature, exploiting nature and so on, we also, through this opposition, create a certain image of nature. And that idealized image of nature is the ultimate obstacle to ecology. So, again, this is why my formula is ecology without nature. The first duty is to drop this heavily ideologically mythological, invested notion of nature." What do you think? What are the two notions of "ecology" he is comparing? Do you agree? 

Paleoclimate

Problem set focused on paleoclimate from the course Climate Physics and Chemistry.

Ocean Physics and Climate

The object of this problem set is to explore climate sensitivity in a slightly more complex version of the multi-level radiative-convective model discussed in class.

Graduate Course Project

Each graduate student taking this class for credit should decide on a term-project. We ask for a 10-page written report (maximum length), and a 20 minute oral presentation to the class before the end of term. Undergraduates do not have to give an oral report (but may, if they wish) and a six-page paper is acceptable. Projects can expand on something covered in class, or be some climate-relevant project not touched upon. In the past, most such projects have been reviews of some interesting topics. A few students have succeeded in doing an original piece of work, but this is certainly not a requirement.

Assignment 1 (Theoretical Environmental Analysis)

Problem set from the class Theoretical Environmental Analysis.

Assignment 2 (Theoretical Environmental Analysis)

Problem set from the class Theoretical Environmental Analysis.

Assignment 3 (Theoretical Environmental Analysis)

Problem set from the class Theoretical Environmental Analysis.

Assignment 4 (Theoretical Environmental Analysis)

Problem set from the class Theoretical Environmental Analysis.

Assignment 5 (Theoretical Environmental Analysis)

Problem set from the class Theoretical Environmental Analysis.

Assignment 6 (Theoretical Environmental Analysis)

Problem set from the class Theoretical Environmental Analysis.

Assignment 7 (Theoretical Environmental Analysis)

Problem set from the class Theoretical Environmental Analysis.

Assignment 8 (Theoretical Environmental Analysis)

Problem set from the class Theoretical Environmental Analysis.

Introductory Exercise

Search your memory for an encounter with a particular bird (it does not need to be a close encounter). Devote one page of your exercise to your description of the bird and its action. Do not include your thoughts or your feelings about the encounter on this page, but do try to evoke the entire sensory experience.

Thoughts on the Readings for Session 2

Imagine that Berry was asked to explain his reservations about Thoreau’s essay. What differences in perspective would he emphasize in his remarks?

William Cronon's "The Trouble with Wilderness; or Getting Back to the Wrong Nature"

Select one or two paragraphs from Cronon’s essay and examine the full range of connections to one other reading from our syllabus. Your own commentary should be 200-300 words long. Be sure to include textual evidence from “The Trouble with Wilderness” and the other work that you consider in your commentary

 

Essay 1

Purpose of assignment:

  • To focus your attention as you read and think about a particular work.
  • To help you distinguish between observed details and the ideas that emerge from those details.
  • To ensure that your own ideas are rooted in specific textual evidence.
Essay 2

You will need to choose two texts to consider in this paper (see below guidelines for a list of works that you may select from), but you should not write an open-ended comparison of the two texts; instead, you should choose an issue or theme that emerges in both of them. Most of you will end up working with writers who share many basic values; you will need to read and think carefully to uncover meaningful distinctions between them.

Essay 3

Your third essay, like the second essay, should explore a question or problem that has emerged from your reading. You may not be able to arrive at an answer or a solution, but over the course of your essay, you should at least be able to refine the central question or identify a range of solutions for your problem. By the end of your third essay, your readers should be able to see what they have gained by exploring this question or problem with you. Stay close to the texts as you explore your chosen issue. Do not wander through the theoretical stratosphere.

Citizen Science & Climate Action

Objective: Provide an overview of citizen science and other collaborative approaches to science-based climate action.

Methane Leaks Hackathon

Objective: Participants get practical background on methane leaks, and initial hands-on experience with the tools for detecting leaks, measuring the volume of gas released from a leak, and tracking and visualizing leaks.

 

Methane Leaks Field trip

Objective: Hands-on field activity collecting data on real-word methane leaks from natural gas infrastructure in Cambridge and Somerville MA. Familiarize two sets of 5–8 participants with the tools and methods.

Legal and Business Actions, Methane Leak Data Debrief

Objectives: Discuss two examples of how data can inform public decision-making: using citizen-collected data in legal cases, and developing a more accurate and consistent measure of the carbon footprints of goods and services. Debrief of methane leak data collected on the prior field trip session.

 

Homework 5 & 6: Sketch 1

Come to class knowing what dataset you are working on, an outline of the story, and a sketch of what you want to make.

Finish your sketch.

Write up your project on the class blog. Start with a summary sentence in the form: "The data say ________. We want to tell this story because _____." Include a 300ish word summary of your data sources and why what you made is an appropriate and effective way to tell the data story.

 

Homework 7 & 8: Sketch 2

Start working on your idea for this sketch. Come to class with with:

  • The data you are going to use (remember to go data shopping!)
  • The audience you want to make something for (remember "general public" is an unacceptable audience!)
  • Good but not required: one abstract word in your data story that you need help representing in concrete ways ("inequality", "hate", "asylum", etc.)

Finish your sketch.

 

Homework 9: How to tell a story

Read Paige Williams, “How to tell a story: The Moth.” Nieman Storyboard (Harvard), August 2012. Choose and listen to one Moth Story. Write down and bring to class your analysis, as Paige Williams lists in her article’s item #3.

Homework 10 & 11: Sketch 3

Start working on your idea for this sketch, and bring into class: data, audience AND goals!

Finish your sketch.

Homework 12 & 13: Sketch 4

Start working on your idea for this sketch, and bring into class: data, audience AND goals!

Finish your sketch.

 

Homework 15: Map Somerville tree data

Use Tableau or CartoDB to make a map of the Somerville MA tree data

 

Homework 16 & 17: Sketch 5

Start working on your idea for this sketch, and bring into class: data, audience, goals, and question.

 

Finish your sketch

 

Final Project

Read the final project requirements. Think about what topic, datasets, and output technique you want to explore for your final project. This could be building on one of the sketches you did before, or starting something new.

Global System for Sustainable Development Database

Submit 10 websites for the Global System for Sustainable Development (GSSD) database via "Submit Site.

 

Midterm Exam

The purpose of this mid-term is for you to:

  • Show your grasp of the challenges in this course
  • Demonstrate your understanding of the reading assignments and relationship to the seminar discussions
  • Show understanding of sustainability issues at this point, and on this basis
  • Obtain some feedback from the instructor as relevant
  • It would be useful to outline your answers before actually writing. Since you will demonstrate familiarity with the assigned readings, please feel free to draw from materials across various weeks - as needed.
Final Exam

Please answer question 1; and then either question 2 or question 3. This is the same type of format and approach as the mid-term.

Suggested length: No fewer than 5 pages and no more than 7 pages for each question, double spaced, not triple spaced with wide margins. (Of course if you can do an excellent essay in less than 5 pages, by all means proceed).

  • Each answer is in essence an 'essay' on the topics you have selected. You must draw on the assigned readings.
  • Do not use the same readings as you did in the mid-term, or focus on the same topic.
  • Since you need to demonstrate familiarity with the assigned readings relevant to each question, feel free to draw from materials across the 13 weeks - as needed.
  • Do not use the same assigned readings for both questions. If you find it necessary to draw on the same assignments, use additional references to make up for the 'double duty factor.'
  • Try to use at least 4 different sources in your answer to each question.
  • For general points, please note that you need the author's name; for specific points noted, you need the author plus the relevant page. Please add your reference list at the end of each question.
Assignment 1 The Earth's Radiation Budget

The global energy balance is important for Earth's climate. When visible radiation from the Sun reaches the Earth, some of it is reflected or scattered directly back into space as shortwave radiation (the percent reflected is known as albedo) and some of it is absorbed. In the absence of clouds, absorption happens mainly at the surface. The absorbed energy warms the Earth's surface, which, in turn, emits this energy at a longer wavelength (infrared rather than visible light).

The purpose of this assignment is to get you thinking about the Earth's radiation budget and the sorts of phenomena which may influence that budget. The description of the datasets is taken from a class taught by Schlosser, Pfirman and Ting at Columbia University.

Exercise 1: Composition of the Mantle

Calculate the composition of the Earth’s Mantle as estimated from the sun’s composition.

Lab 1: Mineral Identification

Although more than 2,000 different mineral species have been identified, only 25 or 30 are abundant constituents of rocks. The purpose of this exercise is to acquaint you with these common rock-forming minerals. The most diagnostic physical properties of these minerals are listed in the Mineral Identification Index.

Lab 2: Rock Identification

This lab constitutes four parts. In the first three sessions, you will familiarize yourselves with the characteristics of – and learn to describe, identify and interpret – the three main types of rock: igneous, sedimentary and metamorphic.

Exercise 2: Rock Structure and Deformation

This exercise is aimed at giving you some practical experience with rock structures and how they appear on the earth’s surface as well as in cross section. 

Lab 3: Geochronology

An introductory lab on geochronology from the course Introduction to Geology.

Lab 4: Plate Tectonics

Lab on plate tectonics. 

 

You have been assigned to one of four scientific specialties and to one of four plates or plate groupings.

The scientific specialties are:

  1. Seismology
  2. Volcanology
  3. Geomorphology
  4. Geochronology

The plates or plate groupings are:

  1. North American Plate
  2. Pacific Plate
  3. African Plate
  4. Eurasian Plate

Each scientific specialty group has been provided a world map showing data relevant to locating plate boundaries and understanding plate boundary processes. Each student will be provided two blank maps. You will mark these as described below and turn them in at the end of the exercise.

Lab 5: Earthquakes Parts 1 and 2

The purpose of today’s lab is to explore the relationship between the velocity of seismic waves and the properties of the materials they travel through (Temperature, pressure, stiffness, density…). We will focus on seismic shear-waves (S-waves), which are elastic vibrations in the direction perpendicular to their direction of propagation.

Exercise 3: Stereonets

This exercise is designed to familiarize you with the basic structure and use of a stereonet, which we use to draw our projections. In this exercise we will actually use equal-area projections rather than true stereographic projections, because they are easier to draw while being just as useful for most purposes

 

Exercise 4: Reading Geological Maps

This laboratory exercise will consist of a set of hypothetical geologic examples to familiarize you with the thought process you'll need to use in interpreting simple problems.

Lab 6: Geological Mapping

In this lab exercise on mapping, you’ll have the chance to get a fairly realistic picture of how geologists go about making a geological map. Think of the lab room as a land area of 10 km2 with no topographic relief. Assume that the land surface is the tabletops, but that there’s enough local relief for you to see bedrock outcrops (i.e. the rocks on the tables).

 

Lab 7: Rivers

This exercise will provide some hands-on experience with methods used for predicting flood frequency and magnitude. We will be using the US Geological Survey (USGS) website to retrieve historical stream gauge data of the sort used to predict the likelihood of flood events of particular magnitudes during a given time interval. Such predictions are the basis for numerous engineering, restoration and development projects in and around rivers.

We will retrieve data for a river in Oregon, use a spreadsheet to analyze the data, and assess the probability of occurrence of floods of particular magnitudes (in terms of discharge), or the likely magnitudes of events of a given recurrence interval. We will then repeat the exercise for the Taunton River in southeastern Massachusetts.

Exercise 5: Science, Policy, and Public Opinion

Your assignment is to research the questions below, and be prepared to argue either side of each issue. The class will be divided into groups, one for each issue, and each issue group will be divided in half: one half will argue in the affirmative, the other in the negative. You will not know which argument you will be making until you arrive in class, so research both sides of the issues! At the beginning of class, you will be given time to prepare your statements. We will then stage a debate for each issue, in which groups respond to questions posed by a moderator

 

Field Trip

Field trip resources and information for Introduction to Geology

Problem Set 1: Salination in Irrigated Agriculture

Modeling activity for the course Ecology II: Engineering for Sustainability.

Problem Set 2: Species Competition

This problem builds on the class lectures about predator-prey ecosytems. Rather than predation, we consider two similar species competing for a common resource. We use the Lotka-Volterra competition model, which embodies the “competitive exclusion” principle:

"If two competing species coexist in the same niche in a stable environment then one species will eventually crowd out the other.”

Problem Set 3: Thermal Analysis for a Small House

In this problem set you will be evaluating the energy performance of a house using a MATLAB model you construct. Your model will include heat gains and losses from heat conduction, convection, and radiation as well as heat gains from a thermostatically controlled furnace. You will be examining the effect of changing windows, and other structural components.

Problem Set 4: MATLAB Practice

This problem set is designed to give you some practice with MATLAB programming. You should develop your own programs rather than modify those handed out in class. The programming problems given here are based on simplified versions of the Exam 1 problems.

Problem Set 5: Particulate Transport

In this problem set you will be simulating particulate emissions from a single vehicle moving along a straight road with a cross wind. You will develop a particle tracking model to visualize the particulate plume and to compute atmospheric concentrations.

Problem Set 6: Resource Allocation

The objective of this problem is to allocate agricultural water to maximize profits, subject to environmental constraints.

Exam 1

Exam questions for the course Ecology II: Engineering for Sustainability

Exam 2

Exam questions for the course Ecology II: Engineering for Sustainability

Group Presentations

Students will be assigned to choose one material represented by each of the three case study groups: glass, metal, or rubber. Each group will research one aspect of the chosen material and make a group presentation at the end of the corresponding unit.

Written Assignments

Each student will be responsible for two short papers on the material from the two units not included in his/her presentation. For example, if a student makes a presentation on metallurgy, the two papers will be on glass and rubber; if the presentation is on rubber processing, the papers will be on metallurgy and glass.

Laboratory

Part of the exploration of the materials and engineering aspects of each case study will be accomplished through hands-on laboratory experience with the materials in question: glass, copper and its alloys, and rubber.

Problem Set 1: Geochronology and the Age of the Solar System

Problem set for the course Physics and Chemistry of Terrestrial Planets. 

Problem Set 2: Moment of Inertia

Problem set for the course Physics and Chemistry of Terrestrial Planets. 

Problem Set 3: Seismology

Problem set for the course Physics and Chemistry of Terrestrial Planets. 

Problem Set 4: Conduction and Subsidence

Problem set for the course Physics and Chemistry of Terrestrial Planets. 

Problem Set 5: Convection

Problem set for the course Physics and Chemistry of Terrestrial Planets. 

Problem Set 6: Geomagnetism and Paleomagnetis

Problem set for the course Physics and Chemistry of Terrestrial Planets. 

Problem Set 7: Ocean Ridge Spreading

Problem set for the course Physics and Chemistry of Terrestrial Planets. 

Problem Set 8: Isostasy

Problem set for the course Physics and Chemistry of Terrestrial Planets. 

Problem Set 9: Gravity

Problem set for the course Physics and Chemistry of Terrestrial Planets. 

Essay

What criteria do you think are important for assessing the habitability of a planetary body? Illustrate with reference to current or past missions in our solar system.

or

What is meant by the concept of Galactic Habitable Zone. Illustrate with reference to a current mission that looks outside our solar system.

Paper

Read the paper Phylogenetic Structure of the Prokaryotic Domain: The Primary Kingdoms and answer the following questions.

Problem Set 1

Problem set for the course Geobiology. 

Problem Set 2

Problem set for the course Geobiology. 

Problem Set 1

Problem set for the course Atmospheric Physics and Chemistry. 

Problem Set 2

Problem set for the course Atmospheric Physics and Chemistry. 

Take Home Exam

Take Home Exam for the course Atmospheric Physics and Chemistry. 

Project 1: Mass and Wind

The purpose of this project is to study, using meteorological observations and laboratory experiments, the relation between the wind field and the mass field in a rotating system. In part I we explore the relationship in laboratory experiments; in part II atmospheric observations of intense cyclones and hurricanes are used.

 

Project 2: Fronts

In this project, we inspect fronts crossing the country associated with day-to-day variations in the weather using real-time atmospheric observations. In the laboratory we create fronts by allowing salty (and hence dense) columns of water to collapse under rotation and gravity. We discover that the observed changes in winds and temperature across our laboratory and atmospheric fronts is consistent with Margule’s formula (a discrete form of the thermal wind equation) and see that the dynamical balance at work in the atmosphere is the same as in the density fronts created in the rotating tank.

 

Project 3: Convection

In this project we enquire into the nature of the convective process. We will simulate convection in the laboratory using a tank of water with a heating pad at its base and study convection in the atmosphere using thermodynamic diagrams.

 

Project 4: General Circulation

In this final project, we draw together some of the ideas explored in Projects 1, 2, and 3 and apply them to study, using atmospheric data and a rotating annulus, aspects of the general circulation of the atmosphere.

 

Emission temperatures and greenhouse models

Problem sets for the Activity: Emission temperatures and greenhouse models

Design@MIT

Consider the objects and products you encounter every day while at MIT—all of these were designed. When looking at a design, it’s important to be critical, but in a constructive manner. It’s also important to recognize that there are very few instances where a design is totally great or totally terrible; there are typically good parts of a poor design, and vice versa.

Take a picture of two very different objects or products, one that you believe is a relatively bad design, and one that is a relatively good design. Discuss the pros and cons of each design, and why you have come to your overall “good” or “bad” conclusion. Also discuss what trade-offs and constraints the designers likely faced in developing these products, and how these challenges were managed.

Discussion Questions 1

Write short answers to the following questions and submit them.

Technology Critique

Interact with and critique technology from a variety of perspectives

Mini-Project: Affordable Rainwater Harvesting System

The goal of the Mini Project is to design an affordable rainwater harvesting system that is made up of several small storage units that can be fit with attachments for drinking, cooking, hand washing and irrigation (and possibly other applications too). We will have a chance to experiment with some of the technologies that may influence the design (SODIS water bags, tippy tap hand washers and IDE drip irrigation kits) in class Ses #4.

 

Discussion Questions 2

Write short answers to the following questions and submit them.

Design Project Work

This is a series of assignments around a design project for the course D-Lab II: Design.

Build-It Module Wrap Up

Build-It modules are hands-on opportunities to learn how to use a variety hand tools, machine tools and prototyping equipment in project-based training sessions. You choose which module to take based on your interest in the project / skills taught, and are encouraged to coordinate with your teams to gain a variety of experiences that you can then share with each other.

Idea Generation and Concept Evaluation

Now that your design problem has been clearly defined and the specifications have been set out, it is time to concentrate on thinking of solutions. 

Detail Design, Analysis and Experimental Results

This assignment prepares for the Phase 3 Design Review of detail design, analysis and experimental results. 

Book Group

The four books that comprise Reading Assignment #7 are divided among four groups of students

  • Small is Beautiful
  • Gaviotas
  • Cradle to Cradle
  • Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid
Wheelchairs and Cook Stoves Assessment

List the design features of each of the wheelchairs and cook stoves shown below that were driven by each of the ‘bilities that we discussed in class. Refer to the reading assignments for additional information on the materials, techniques and processes used in the manufacture of both wheelchairs and cook stoves. On a separate page, discuss what you think were the major drivers of each design, and what trade-offs were made. 

Final Presentation

The Final Presentations will take place at the MIT Museum on the Saturday before our last week of class. The schedule of the event will be as follows:

  • The instructor for each class will give a 2 minutes introduction for the class and introduce the projects
  • Each team will give a 1 minute presentation about their project
  • Each team will be given a space at the Museum to showcase their project. You will be asked to bring your prototype and a poster that gives an overview of the project
Embodied Energy Evaluation

Embodied Energy Evaluation

Final Report

Design reports give design engineers the chance to catalog the design process, describe how they came to the decisions they came to, and explain the rationale behind those decisions. As a team, write a 10–15 page report describing your project.

Design for Production

When designing a product that is to be produced beyond just the prototype stage, attention must be given to the resources that are available and to the sustainability of the manufacturing processes. 

As a team, determine the appropriate scale of manufacturing for your project: will they be made in the tens, hundreds, or millions? What design changes will need to be made as you shift from manufacture of a single prototype to the production of multiple units?

Short Journal Article 1

For this assignment, you will write a short (1000 words or less) journal-style communication briefly describing your findings on the research portion of this design project.

Short Journal Article

This second journal article should be a brief (1,500 words or less) compendium of the technical results that YOU specifically have contributed to your group’s work. It’s OK if you worked in pairs with someone, though please try to distinguish what you did if possible

 

Research Paper

A research paper relating to topics discussed in class will be the main assignment focus throughout the course [for people and other animals]. Undergraduate students must write a paper of a minimum of 12 pages, while graduate students have a minimum length of 25 pages.

Weekly Responses

Weekly Responses for the people and other animals section. 

 

Section 3: Aerosol and Clouds

Lab handouts for Section 3 of experiemental atmospheric chemistry. 

Problem Set 3

Problem Set 3 for Modeling Environmental Complexity

 

Problem Set 2

Problem Set 2 for the Modeling Environmental Complexity

 

Midterm Exam

Midterm exam for Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics fluid dynamics 

Section 2: CO2 and Climate Change

Lab on CO2 and Climate Change for Experimental Atmospheric Chemistry.

Section 1: Atmospheric Photochemistry and Air Pollution

Lab on Atmospheric Photochemistry and Air Pollution for Experimental Atmospheric Chemistry.

Problem Set 1

Problem set for the course Modeling Environmental Complexity.

Ocean Circulation II

Problem Set for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

Ocean Circulation I

Problem set for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

Atmospheric Circulation

Problem set for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

Geostrophic balance

Problem set for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

Convection and moist processes (cont.)

Problem set for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

Convection and moist processes

Problem set for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

Hydrostatic balance and lapse rate

Problem set for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDXIV: Thermohaline Circulation

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDXIII: Ocean Gyres

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDXII: Ekman Pumping and Suction

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDXI: Atmospheric General Circulation

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDX: Ekman Layers

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDIX: Slope of a Frontal Surface

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDVIII: Thermal Wind and Hadley Circulation

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDVII: Taylor Column

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDVI: Perrot’s Bathtub Experiment

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDV: Inertial Circles

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDIV: Parabolic Table

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDIII: Radial Inflow

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDII: Convection

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFDI: Cloud Formation on Adiabatic Expansion

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

GFD0: Rotation Stiffens Fluids

Demonstration for the course Atmosphere, Ocean and Climate Dynamics

Homework 9

Problem set for the course Transport Processes in the Environment.

Homework 8

Problem set for the course Transport Processes in the Environment.

Homework 7

Problem set for the course Transport Processes in the Environment.

Homework 6

Problem set for the course Transport Processes in the Environment.

Homework 5

Problem set for the course Transport Processes in the Environment.

Homework 4

Problem set for the course Transport Processes in the Environment.

Homework 3

Problem set for the course Transport Processes in the Environment.

Homework 2

Problem set for the course Transport Processes in the Environment.

Homework 1

Problem set for the course Transport Processes in the Environment.

Lab 10: Atmosphere-Water Exchange

You will estimate the rate of exchange between a water body (the flume) and the overlying air for two volatile compounds, molecular oxygen and chloroform. You will use an oxygen electrode to measure the changing concentration of oxygen, and gas chromatography (GC) to observe the concentration of chloroform.

Lab 8: Dissolution of the Gypsum and the Laminar Sub-Layer

You will use two methods to estimate the laminar sub-layer thickness in the laboratory flume. The first method is based on the observed dissolution rate of Gypsum bars, and is described below. 

 

Lab 4: Transport in Porous Media

Objective: Use a tracer study to estimate the dispersion coefficient, pore velocity and porosity of a sediment column. 

Lab 3: Residence Time Distribution and System Circulation

Objectives: Estimate detention time and nominal residence time in a model basin

Lab 2: Measuring Velocity in a Channel

Goals: Measure the mean velocity in the laboratory flume using two different methods, and determine whether these estimates agree within the uncertainty.

 

Project

Research proposal describing a pilot project for assessing an Earth system-scale geoengineering technology

Exam #3

Approximately 50% of the quiz will cover new material: everything from Lecture 14 (Human Population Growth on November 3rd) through Lecture 18 (Prof. Sterman’s Lecture on November 19th) including competition and the niche, predation, and biogeography. The remaining 50% will be cumulative, and may cover anything from Lecture 1 through Lecture 13.  This includes the early earth, redox reactions, energy transformations and metabolism, biogeochemical cycles, the carbon cycle, primary and secondary productivity, Redfield ratio and limiting factors, ecosystem experiments, food webs, population growth, chemostats, and life tables.  Like Quiz 1 and 2, the questions will be primarily short answer, which can be responded to with a few sentences, a sketch with a description, or a brief calculation. We could also ask you to interpret a graph/data or give you a discussion question. Use Problem Sets 1-3, the Quiz 3 Study Questions, the Lecture Notes, and the Lecture Handouts as a top priority for studying. Make sure you are familiar with the articles that have been assigned. Remember to bring a calculator! 

Exam #2

The quiz will cover everything from Lecture 8 (Global Carbon Cycle on October 6th ) through Lecture 13 (Chemostats/Life Tables on October 29th ) including Redfield ratio and limiting factors, ecosystem experiments, geoengineering, secondary productivity, food webs, population growth, chemostats, and life tables. Like Quiz 1, the questions will be primarily short answer, which can be responded to with a few sentences, a sketch with a description, or a brief calculation. We could also ask you to interpret a graph/data or give you a discussion question. Remember to bring a calculator! 

 

Exam #1

The quiz will cover everything through Lecture 7 (Biogeochemical cycles) including redox, primary productivity, and the thermodynamics of life. The questions will be primarily short answer, which can be responded to with a few sentences, a sketch with a description, or a brief calculation. We could also ask you to interpret a graph/data or give you a discussion question. 

Problem Set 3

Problem set for the course Ecology I: The Earth System.

Problem Set 2

Problem set for the course Ecology I: The Earth System.

Problem Set 1

Problem set for the course Ecology I: The Earth System.


Learn More

Visit the Pedagogical Practices Explainers page to learn more about specific teaching practices mentioned within these lessons.

Learn about the Framework that was used with the various course materials!